Challenges of Transferring Goodwill from a Sole Proprietorship to a Corporation

To schedule an appointment, contact our law firm at 403-400-4092 or Chris@NeufeldLegal.com

When lawyers suggest tax strategies for undertaking structural legal arrangements to resolve a particular business tax problem, there tends to be considerable monetary value associated with those proposed strategies. Such a business tax challenge arises with the transfer of goodwill from a sole proprietorship to a corporation, with the associated problems being focused on valuation, tax implications, and legal compliance; such that appropriate tax strategies are demanded.

A. Valuation Challenges

Goodwill is an intangible asset - it's the value of a business beyond its physical assets, including its reputation, brand recognition, customer loyalty, and long-term relationships.

  • Difficulty in Quantification: Unlike tangible assets (like equipment), goodwill doesn't usually appear on a sole proprietor's balance sheet and is highly subjective to value. Accurately determining its Fair Market Value (FMV) is a significant hurdle.

  • Personal vs. Commercial Goodwill: A large portion of a sole proprietorship's goodwill may be personal (tied directly to the owner's skills and reputation). This personal goodwill may be difficult to transfer or retain its value within a corporate structure, as buyers/customers may associate the business's success primarily with the individual owner, not the new entity.

  • Professional Appraisal: To withstand scrutiny from the Canada Revenue Agency (CRA), a formal business valuation by a qualified professional (e.g., a Chartered Business Valuator or CPA) is often required. This adds complexity and cost to the incorporation process.

B. Tax and Compliance Challenges

The transfer of assets, including goodwill, from a proprietor (an individual) to a new corporation (a separate legal entity) is generally considered a taxable event - a deemed sale at fair market value.

  • Potential for Immediate Capital Gains Tax: If the goodwill is transferred at its FMV, and that FMV is greater than its original cost base (which is often $0 for self-generated goodwill), the sole proprietor could realize a significant capital gain on their personal tax return, resulting in an immediate and potentially large tax bill.

  • Section 85 Rollover (Income Tax Act (Canada)): To defer this immediate tax liability, business owners often use a statutory mechanism, such as a Section 85 rollover. This election allows the owner to transfer eligible property (including goodwill) to the corporation at an "elected amount" (typically the original cost base, or ACB) instead of the FMV.

    • Complexity and Cost: Executing a Section 85 rollover correctly requires precise legal documentation (a rollover agreement) and the timely filing of specific tax forms (e.g., CRA's T2057), which demands the expertise of a tax professional (CPA and/or lawyer) and adds administrative cost.

    • Ineligible Assets: Certain assets, like accounts receivable, may be ineligible for the full tax-deferred rollover and must be handled separately, further complicating the transfer.

  • Documentation and Audit Risk: Proper documentation of the transfer, the determined FMV, and the elected amount is crucial. Failure to correctly document the transaction or to file the necessary forms can lead to tax reassessments, penalties, and interest if the tax authority reviews the transaction and deems a different FMV or an incorrect procedure was followed.

C. Legal and Administrative Challenges

The legal and administrative steps must be executed precisely to ensure the transfer is effective and compliant.

  • Legal Agreement: A formal Purchase and Sale Agreement or Rollover Agreement must be drafted between the sole proprietor and the new corporation, clearly outlining the transfer of goodwill and other assets and the consideration received (typically shares in the new corporation).

  • Licensing and Contracts: Customer and supplier contracts, licenses, leases, and permits that were in the name of the individual sole proprietor may need to be formally assigned or re-issued to the new corporation to ensure continuity, which can be an administrative burden.

  • Registration Changes: The corporate structure change requires updating numerous registrations, including business numbers, tax accounts (e.g., GST/HST), and sometimes legal name or ownership records with government agencies.

Providing corporate-commercial legal advice and strategic direction to business enterprises engaged as Alberta provincial corporations or federal corporations, from business formation to corporate governance to contracts and business transactions. Contact our law firm at Chris@NeufeldLegal.com or 403-400-4092 to schedule a confidential initial consultation for your business.

Canadian-Controlled Private Corporation (CCPC)